Welcome to our board! Log In Create A New Profile
Use mobile view

Advanced

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

February 14, 2016 07:20PM
I agree that Jane Austen knew what and who she was writing about and very young girls marrying was quite the norm in the Regency era (did not Mrs Bennet think Jane might have got an off from a gentleman when she was but fifteen? Lydia was married at just turned sixteen in her next work, Pride and Prejudice ) .

What I sometimes wonder is if our perceptions of her characters are too coloured or influenced by watching modern adaptations? Did Colonel Brandon actually look somewhat like the late Alan Rickman, or Marriane Dashwood vaguely resemble Kate Winslett? Was Darcy anything like Colin Firth? Elizabeth was but tolerable in looks until the intelligence in her dark eyes attracted Darcy's interest rather than her pretty looks. I suspect that we possibly sometimes assume this to be the case when Jane Austen may have had much more plain and ordinary looking characters than Hollywood's finest in mind. Colonel Fitzwilliam was not a handome man, neither I think was Colonel Brandon. How much like a silver screen hero was Mr Knightley? Their main attraction was one of great consequence in middle class life, that of money and financial security. They all owned large properties. "Handsome is as handsome does" is an old mandate. Did it apply in Jane Austen's world?

Wickham would have married the plain and freckled Mary King because of money and regardless of lack of beauty. The George Wickhams' John Willoughbys' Frank Churchills etc were all allowed to be handsome charming fellows but shallow and false in reality. Did Jane Austen stereotype her villains this way purposely? Her father, someone she loved dearly, was a normal working and poorish clergyman with a large family and never described as handsome. Sense and Sensibilty being her first major novel, what exactly did she have in mind? Since she rarely described her characters other than briefly, it is something of an intruiging question. It must have been so in the minds of film directors also when casting.
SubjectAuthorPosted

Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

KaydeeFebruary 13, 2016 03:46PM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

AmytatFebruary 16, 2016 08:44PM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

Agnes BeatrixFebruary 15, 2016 08:33PM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

Harvey S.February 15, 2016 04:33AM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

Rae ElaineFebruary 15, 2016 02:20AM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

Rae ElaineFebruary 14, 2016 06:29PM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

Agnes BeatrixFebruary 15, 2016 08:02PM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

Jim G.MFebruary 14, 2016 07:20PM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

AmytatFebruary 16, 2016 08:57PM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

Jim G.MFebruary 16, 2016 09:20PM

Re: Frank Churchill's haircut

Agnes BeatrixFebruary 17, 2016 07:37AM

Jane Austen's handsome father

JanetRFebruary 15, 2016 11:16AM

Re: Jane Austen's handsome father

Jim G.MFebruary 15, 2016 11:43AM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

NN SFebruary 14, 2016 03:19PM

Christopher?

JanetRFebruary 14, 2016 05:35PM

Re: Christopher?

NN SFebruary 14, 2016 06:17PM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

Suzanne OFebruary 14, 2016 06:07AM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

Jim G.MFebruary 14, 2016 12:30AM

Original title of Sense & Sensibility

JanetRFebruary 14, 2016 08:22AM

Re: Original title of Sense & Sensibility

Jim G.MFebruary 14, 2016 11:50AM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

PeterFebruary 13, 2016 08:09PM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

LilyFebruary 17, 2016 11:37AM

Re: Col. Brandon & Elinor: Did Austen get the ending of Sense & Sensibility wrong?

PeterFebruary 19, 2016 01:21PM



Author:

Your Email:


Subject:


Spam prevention:
Please, solve the mathematical question and enter the answer in the input field below. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
Question: how much is 23 plus 13?
Message: